The Yellow Vests Have France’s Attention, but What Exactly Are They Saying?

Judah Grunstein, WPR, PARIS:
What to make of the Yellow Vests? For a third week in a row, they continue to dominate the news.Televised scenes of pitched street battles between protesters and police on Saturday raised alarm about an “insurrectional atmosphere” unseen in France since May 1968. Reports suggested that French President Emmanuel Macron might declare a state of emergency in response.

Instead, in his first sign of retreat since taking office in May 2017, Macron agreed yesterday to suspend the planned fuel tax hike that served as the catalyst for the popular mobilizations that have transfixed, if not exactly paralyzed, the country.

Many pixels have been devoted to the movement’s blurry origins, its inchoate and amorphous structure, its lack of leaders and representatives, and its strange combination of demands that range from the issue-specific revolt against the gas tax hike to broad condemnations of social inequality and Macron himself. And yet, for all that, most observers—including, it seems, Macron and the government of his prime minister, Edouard Philippe—continue to grope for answers to basic questions about the Yellow Vests, or Gilets Jaunes, as they are known here.

Who are they? What do they represent? And why are observers here in France so alarmed?

It’s hard to get a sense of who the movement comprises, because it is a social media-based affair and most of the reporting on its supporters is anecdotal. But what seems clear is that the protesters who burned cars, vandalized the Arc de Triomphe, fought riot police and shocked television viewers around the world are not representative of the movement and probably aren’t even part of it. The violence was mostly the work of a hard-core demographic known here as “casseurs,” or breakers, who are to French political protests what hooligans are to soccer stadiums. For them, the violence is central, and whatever protest they join to engage in it is often irrelevant. And if things spiraled so badly out of control, it was in large part because the French security forces’ tactical deployment in anticipation of the violence was ill-conceived and easily bypassed. 

As for the actual Yellow Vests, the admittedly anecdotal reporting suggests a disparate demographic that ranges from mid-level managers and entrepreneurs on one end of the spectrum to low-wage workers on the other. That would seem to correspond to the two income brackets negatively affected by Macron’s tax reforms, namely the upper fifth of the income range—excluding the top centile that benefited enormously—and the bottom quarter. But as Art Goldhammer points out, the impact at the lower end is negligible, leading him to conclude, “To me, these graphs suggest 1) that the movement may not be as widespread as it appears, and 2) that economic motives alone cannot account for the ferocity of the protest.”

What then accounts for this sudden ferocity, and what is it expressing? To begin with, there is clearly some economic content to the upwelling of popular discontent. The tax burden required to fund France’s social welfare model has become heavier over the years, and wages have not kept pace. That’s a cautionary tale to both those on the left, who defend the model, and those on the right who advocate for neoliberal structural reforms to reinvigorate the economy. Macron campaigned on a platform of “flexicurity” that sought to harmonize the two competing poles of the debate. Since taking office, however, he has been accused of governing only from the right, front-loading his labor market reforms, the flexibility for employers, while putting expanded unemployment benefits, or security for workers, on the back burner. But the nature of the European Union’s budgetary guidelines and the demands of competing in a globalized economy make the kind of balancing act he promised a tall order with all but the most stoic of populations, and no one would describe the French as stoic.

If the Yellow Vests organize themselves spontaneously to engage in direct democracy, it is in part because they feel there is no one left to represent them.

There is also political content to the Yellow Vest movement, despite the fact that its members have kept the established political parties at a distance. In fact, that refusal to be appropriated by or affiliated with the parties is itself an expression of political opposition. It is most clearly an opposition to Macron, who has become the personal target of much of the movement’s sloganeering. But it is also an opposition to the political class writ large, an expression of disenfranchisement. 

Part of that disenfranchisement stems from the challenges of managing a wealthy but moderately sized economy embedded within a massive trade bloc and a globalized economy. The loss of sovereignty to the EU and the outsourcing of jobs to low-wage countries have been fueling the rise of the far right and far left in France and across Europe since the global financial crisis. 

That has been exacerbated in France by two developments: the implosion of the established political parties in 2017, which cleared the way for Macron’s victory as a dark horse presidential contender and was subsequently sealed into place by the massive parliamentary majority won by his movement-turned-party; and the demise of France’s organized labor movement as a credible counterbalance to executive power. If the Yellow Vests organize themselves spontaneously to engage in direct democracy, it is in part because they feel there is no one left to represent them. As Goldhammer put it in an email correspondence on the subject, there is no communication “in either direction owing to the absence of recognized intermediaries.” In France’s currently barren political landscape, if the Yellow Vests didn’t exist, they’d have to be invented.

Finally, there is a social content to the Yellow Vests’ popular revolt, a feeling of neglect and exclusion that both feeds and is fed by the sense of political disenfranchisement. The most attention-grabbing protests took place in Paris, but the real misery they express is being felt most acutely in the exurbs and rural regions across the country. This is not only where inhabitants are most dependent on their cars for transportation. It is also where the French state and many institutions representative of French society have progressively disengaged over the past decade. This neglect is most visible in small villages, where post offices have closed, doctors and health care disappeared, and government funding dried up. But it is felt across wide swaths of the country, where opportunity for social and economic advancement has receded and no one in the urban enclaves of affluence bothered to notice.

To be sure, these are sparsely populated parts of the country, especially compared to the urban centers. I suspect Goldhammer is correct when he says the movement might not be as widespread as it seems. To put things further in perspective, as shocking as the scenes of violence Saturday were, the protests were invisible to most Parisians who weren’t watching their TVs that day. 

Why, then, are they causing such alarm? Why did they cause Macron, who has stared down the unions twice already over previous reform packages, to blink? Perhaps it is precisely because the Yellow Vests are not channeled by France’s recognized intermediaries, which makes them less disciplined, less predictable and less tameable than what France’s political class is accustomed to. If the Yellow Vests are dangerous, it is less for what they are than for what they reveal: an unrepresented constituency in a representative democracy. They’re the tip of an iceberg that has gone unnoticed until now, and no one is sure exactly what remains to be discovered under the water’s surface.

Related Pictures:

Related News:

Krishna H Pushkar - 2019-07-21

- 2019-07-21

कम्मरमा २ किलो सुन ! - 2019-07-21

हत्या आरोप लागेपछि एक महिनादेखि ३ वडाअध्यक्ष फरार - 2019-07-21

नोबल मेडिकल कलेजमा नाराबाजी - 2019-07-21

Sri Lanka expels 200 Islamic clerics after Easter attacks - 2019-05-06

Dailymirror:Sri Lanka has expelled over 600 foreign nationals, including around 200 Islamic clerics, since the Easter suicide bombings blamed on a local jihadi group, a minister told AFP Sunday. Home Affairs Minister Vajira Abeywardena said the clerics had entered the country legally, but amid a security crackdown after the attacks were found to have overstayed their visas, for which fines were imposed and they were expelled from the island.

Sri Lanka Easter attack toll hits 290 - 2019-04-22

Agency:At least 290 are now known to have died in a series of bomb blasts that tore through churches and luxury hotels in Sri Lanka, in the worst violence to hit the island since its devastating civil war ended a decade ago. Eight apparently co-ordinated explosions targeted Easter worshippers and high end hotels popular with international guests.

Zelensky wins Ukraine's presidential election - 2019-04-22

Xinhua: The national exit poll showed on Sunday that Ukrainian actor Volodymyr Zelensky won the country's presidential election by gaining 73.2 percent of the votes in the second round as of 6 p.m. local time (1500 GMT), the Ukrainian government-run Ukrinform news agency said.

12 Nepalese women, bar owner arrested in Nyali sex trafficking swoop - 2019-04-14

By ANTHONY KITIMO:Twelve Nepalese women were arrested in a raid at New Rangeela Bar and Restaurant in Nyali, Mombasa County, early Saturday in what police said was an operation against human trafficking. Police said the operation targeted an international sex trafficking syndicate, a kind of human trafficking for purposes of sexual exploitation.

U.S. to leave 200 troops in Syria after pullout - 2019-02-22

Xinhua: The White House said Thursday that the United States would leave a small proportion of troops in Syria after the planned pullout. "A small peacekeeping group of about 200 will remain in Syria for a period of time," White House Press Secretary Sarah Sanders said in a statement.

Venezuela seals border with Brazil - 2019-02-22

Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro on Thursday ordered the country's southern border with Brazil be sealed off. "I have decided: in south Venezuela, starting at 8 p.m. today Thursday Feb. 21, the land border with Brazil will be totally and absolutely closed," said Maduro. The measure will be in effect until further notice, the president said during a meeting with the high command of the National Bolivarian Armed Forces.

Richard Branson faces competition from Maduro with rival concert on Venezuela's border - 2019-02-19

Alexandra Gibbs:Less than a week after business magnate Richard Branson announced that he was organizing a "Live Aid"-style music benefit to tackle Venezuela's humanitarian crisis-it appears that the country's government has similar plans of its own.

Russia to Parade Syrian War Trophies in Cross Country Tour - 2019-02-06

MoscowRussia’s military has announced plans to showcase the weapons and equipment it seized in Syria on a tour across the country. Moscow has fought on the side of the Syrian government in its civil war since 2015.

Ekushey TV chief reporter arrested on sexual harassment charges - 2019-02-06

Bangladesh:The Rapid Action Battalion or RAB has arrested Ekushey Television Chief Reporter MM Sekandar on charges of attempt to sexually harass a female colleague. A RAB-2 team arrested Sekandar at his home in Dhaka's Banasree early on Monday morning following a complaint lodged by the alleged victim, Superintendent of Police Mohiuddin Faruqui, who is working in the RAB, told bdnews24.com

Lunar New Year's Eve dinners across China - 2019-02-04

The dinner on the Lunar New Year's Eve is considered one of the most important meals on the Chinese calendar. So what's being served across dinner tables in China to mark the start of the "Year of the Pig"?

Trump visits border amid US shutdown wall row - 2019-01-11

US President Donald Trump has threatened again to declare a national emergency to fund a border wall without Congress's approval. "I have the absolute right to declare a national emergency," he told reporters as he headed to an event at the border. He also said Mexico would "indirectly" pay for the wall - contradicting an earlier campaign memo.

Brexit: Japan's PM says 'wish of whole world' to avoid no-deal - 2019-01-11

bbc:The "whole world" wants the UK to avoid a no-deal Brexit, Japan's PM has claimed, after talks with Theresa May. Shinzo Abe pledged "total support" for the withdrawal agreement she has negotiated with the EU, which faces a crunch vote in the Commons on Tuesday.

Reeling From a Family Drama, Czech PM Babis Courts the Political Extremes - 2018-12-11

Tim Gosling, PRAGUE:A billionaire with a short fuse, a dim view of the democratic process and a long list of suspicious business dealings, Czech Prime Minister Andrej Babis now looks set to head further toward the populist margins ever since his son claimed to have been kidnapped on Babis’ orders.

Macron, Merkel, May: Drama, Tragedy and Farce in the EU - 2018-12-11

Judah Grunstein:Her many shortcomings notwithstanding, British Prime Minister Theresa May has a singular ability to bear humiliations with dignity.

China to launch new-generation retrievable satellite in 2019 - 2018-12-10

China: China will launch a reusable retrievable satellite next year, with its recoverable module able to be used 15 times over the next decade, according to the China Aerospace Science & Technology Corp.

ganda Went From Being a Model of Refugee Response to a Cautionary Tale - 2018-12-10

Andrew Green,WPR:The international community has long lauded Uganda for its response to the massive influx of South Sudanese refugees who have fled across the border since the start of that country’s conflict in 2013. As the number of arrivals climbed into the hundreds of thousands, Kampala maintained an open-door policy and committed increasing amounts of land for agencies to construct temporary settlements and for refugees to build permanent shelters.

Don’t Count on the Truce Holding in Trump’s Trade War With China - 2018-12-05

Kimberly Ann Elliott:As widely expected, U.S. President Donald Trump and his Chinese counterpart Xi Jinping declared a truce in their trade war over dinner in Buenos Aires this past weekend. According to the White House statement after the meeting, Xi committed to increase imports of American agricultural and energy products to reduce the bilateral trade deficit and to immediately begin negotiations over China’s unfair trade policies.

The Yellow Vests Have France’s Attention, but What Exactly Are They Saying? - 2018-12-05

Judah Grunstein, WPR, PARIS:What to make of the Yellow Vests? For a third week in a row, they continue to dominate the news.Televised scenes of pitched street battles between protesters and police on Saturday raised alarm about an “insurrectional atmosphere” unseen in France since May 1968. Reports suggested that French President Emmanuel Macron might declare a state of emergency in response.

How George H.W. Bush Set the U.N. Up for Post-Cold War Success-and Failure - 2018-12-03

Richard Gowan:George Herbert Walker Bush grasped the importance of the United Nations like no other American president before or since. The 41st occupant of the White House, who died last week, was U.S. ambassador to the U.N. in the early 1970s. Yet his main contribution to the institution came at the end of the Cold War.

‘Year of the Debacle’: How Nigeria Lost Its Way in the War Against Boko Haram - 2018-11-28

Obi Anyadike, MAIDUGURI: Nigeria—Lirfa Dashe, a lieutenant in the Nigerian army, was due to get married this month. Instead he is buried in the cemetery of Mai Malari barracks, alongside other soldiers killed in the seemingly endless conflict against the jihadist insurgency of Boko Haram.

For the EU at the U.N., Rising Influence but Bad Timing - 2018-11-28

Richard Gowan,WPR: Is the European Union becoming an effective diplomatic force in the Security Council? Advocates of a common EU foreign policy have long called on the bloc to play a greater role at the United Nations. Germany is even formally committed to the idea of an EU seat on the council. The union has gradually become more prominent in the General Assembly as well as in debates on development aid over the past two decades. But it has not had the same impact in the Security Council.

Powered by: Exclusively Solution